Deferred Compensation Plans vs. 401(k)s: What’s the Difference?

Oct 16, 2023 By Susan Kelly

Employees who participate in deferred compensation plans have an additional choice for saving for retirement, and these programs are often employed as an addition to 401(k) plans. Deferred compensation is just a scheme that enables workers to postpone receiving a portion of their regular salary until after a certain point in time in the future. According to how the law defines each of these various plans, their operational procedures are distinct from one another. A person who is 55 years old and earns $249,999 per year, for instance, has the option of delaying $49,999 of their annual income for the following ten years until they are 65 years old and eligible for retirement. So, deferred compensation plans vs. 401(k)s: what’s the difference. We will break down here the difference between them.


Deferred Compensation Plans


Money from deferred compensation is saved until the worker is ready to get it. Until then, they can get their money back. At the time of the deferral, the employee pays taxes on the deferred income just like they do on the rest of their income. But the employee doesn't have to pay income tax on the deferred compensation until the money is received. Most of the time, high-paid managers who don't require their yearly pay to meet their needs and want to pay less in taxes utilize deferred compensation) plans. With a deferred compensation plan, a person's taxable income decreases while they save the money.


401(k) Plans



One cause deferred compensation plans are frequently used to augment a 401(k) or an IRA is that you can put so much cash into the schemes than you could into a 401(k), approximately 50 percent of your pay. In 2022, you could set - up to $20,499 per year into your 401(k). So, a high-income worker who makes $799,999 could only put $22,499 ($20,499 divided by $799,999) into their 401(k) (k). The Internal Revenue Service does not limit plans for delayed pay (IRS).


Key Differences


Most 401(k) plans don't give you as many investment options as deferred compensation plans do, but they do. Most of the time, you can't do anything with deferred compensation funds before the date set for distribution. When the plan is set up, the distribution date must be chosen and cannot be changed. It can happen when they retire or after a certain amount of time. Also, you can't use money from deferred compensation to get a loan.


Danger of Forfeiture



The money could be lost, which is one of the biggest risks of a deferred compensation plan. It is much less safe than a 401(k) plan. Plans that payout in the future is funded informally. It's a promise from the employer to pay the employee the deferred funds plus any investment earnings at a particular time. On the other hand, a 401(k) is an official account. Because deferred compensation plans are not official, the employee becomes one of the employer's debtors. Insurance is built into a 401(k) plan.


If, on the other hand, the employer goes out of business, there is no guarantee that the employee will ever get the deferred compensation money. The employee is just another creditor of the company in this case. They are behind people who own bonds and preferred stock. Most of the time, it's best to use a deferred compensation plan only after you've put as much as you can into a 401(k) plan.


Why Is Deferred Compensation Best Than a 401(k)?


People who make a lot of money and want to pay less in taxes often think that deferred compensation is better than a 401(k). Also, you can put much more money into a deferred compensation plan than you can into a 401(k). The essential things about deferred compensation plans are that the employee does not "get" the money right away. A deferred compensation plan is not as safe as a 401(k), where contributions are held in a trust and are safe from the employer's creditors. Instead, the employee's only right under the plan is to pay that was put off. The employee risks that the employer will have enough money when the time comes to pay the deferred compensation.


Conclusion


The 401(k) plan is a sort of deferred compensation plan, although it operates differently from other types of deferred compensation plans in general. NQDC plans, 401(k) plans, and 457 plans belong to the same group, as we will see in the next chapter of this book. 401(k) plans, however, are distinct from the other two.

Related articles
An Overview to the 529 Plan Withdrawals for Private School

Tax-free distributions from 529 plans for elementary, middle, and high school tuition are now possible, thanks to the tax cuts enacted in 2017. The law also permits a tax-free and penalty-free conversion of traditional 529 plans into 529 ABLE plans. This article has been updated to reflect any new information regarding this and other 529 plan features that may become available after 2022.

Dec 15, 2023 Susan Kelly

A Complete Guide to What Is Bank Credit?

A "bank credit" is a loan that a bank offers to its customers to meet their personal or business needs, with or without a guarantee or collateral, to earn a periodic interest rate on the loan amount. At the end of the loan term, the principal will be returned to you, as agreed upon and stated in the loan agreement.

Jan 08, 2024 Triston Martin

Can You Please Calculate The Return Before Taxes

Regarding investment returns, "pretax" means that the return was determined before taxes were taken off. As everyone's tax situation is different and different assets are taxed at varying rates, the pretax rate of return is the most commonly cited metric for investments in the financial sector. Return on investment (ROI) after taxes is comparable to before taxes

Dec 21, 2023 Triston Martin

Deferred Compensation Plans vs. 401(k)s: What’s the Difference?

Both types of plans, in general, defer payment because the employee has chosen to wait to get cash in hand to get some other benefit, such as delaying the payment of taxes on the money or investing while delaying the payment of taxes. Some examples of these types of benefits include: delaying the payment of taxes on the money or investing while delaying the payment of taxes.

Oct 16, 2023 Susan Kelly

Sears Home Warranty Review 2022 in Detail

Compared to other home warranty providers, Sears Home Warranty's 180-day warranty on approved repairs is quite lengthy. While three service plans are available nationwide (except in Alaska and Hawaii), the cost of optional upgrades is high. The whole contiguous United States other than Alaska and Puerto Rico are included in the coverage area.

Feb 06, 2024 Susan Kelly

Pros and cons of certificates of deposit (CDs)

Investing your money can be a daunting process. Discover the pros and cons of investing in CDs so you can decide whether this is the best method for reaching your financial goals.

Oct 02, 2023 Triston Martin